Magnetic Snap Rivet Setter vs Chicago Screw Tool
By Klum House: Bag making kits, bag sewing patterns, waxed | Published: 2026-10-20
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Magnetic Snap Rivet Setter and Chicago Screw Tool for bag making. Learn which hardware tool fits your project needs and why.
Quick answer
Choose the Magnetic Snap Rivet Setter if you need a dedicated tool for setting magnetic snap rivets cleanly. Pick the Chicago Screw Tool if you work with Chicago screws and want a reliable, strong set without damaging hardware.
What each tool does best
The Magnetic Snap Rivet Setter is purpose-built for installing magnetic snap rivets in sizes 18mm and 14mm. Its concave strike post protects the rivet cap's roundness, and the two included anvils match the male and female sides of the rivet. This tool ensures the two halves align and click together perfectly every time.
The Chicago Screw Tool is designed specifically for tightening Chicago screws. While a flathead screwdriver can work, this tool's rubber grips let you achieve a much stronger, more reliable set that holds up to years of wear. It is especially recommended for projects like the Fremont Tote.
Key trade-offs to consider
The Magnetic Snap Rivet Setter is specialized: it only works with magnetic snap rivets of those two sizes. If your project uses different hardware, this tool won't help.
The Chicago Screw Tool is similarly specialized for Chicago screws. It cannot set rivets or install other hardware types. However, its rubber grips provide a level of torque and control that a screwdriver cannot match.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Tool specialization: Magnetic Snap Rivet Setter works only with 18mm and 14mm magnetic snap rivets. Chicago Screw Tool works only with Chicago screws.
- Ease of use: Rivet setter includes dedicated anvils for each side of the rivet. Screw tool's rubber grips provide better torque than a screwdriver.
- Durability of result: Rivet setter produces a clean, aligned snap closure. Screw tool delivers a strong, long-lasting set that resists loosening.
- Versatility: Neither tool works with other hardware types. Choose based on the fastener your project requires. If your bag uses both types of hardware, you may need both tools.
Product facts at a glance
- Magnetic Snap Rivet Setter: Includes a metal strike post with a concave end that protects the roundness of the magnetic snap rivet cap, plus two anvils for male and female sides. This design prevents damage to the rivet cap and ensures the two sides align and click together perfectly.
Magnetic Snap Rivet Setter - Chicago Screw Tool: Rubber grips allow you to get an extra-strong, reliable set that holds up to years of wear and tear. The extra grip means your Chicago screws stay tight longer, even in high-use bags like totes.
Chicago Screw Tool
Which tool fits your project?
Best for
- Bag makers installing magnetic snap rivets on bags, wallets, or accessories who want a clean, professional finish.
- Sewists working with Chicago screws on high-use items like totes or backpacks who need a secure, long-lasting set.
Not for
- Projects that use only one type of fastener and do not require the other tool.
- Bag makers who need a multi-purpose hardware tool for different fastener types.
